Breeders’ Cup 2019: Racing Faces Perilous Situation

By Mike Farrell

Santa Anita Park.

Lieutenant Colonel George Armstrong Custer and the brave men of the 7th Cavalry Regiment saddled up and rode off into the Black Hills one final time on a fateful day in 1876.

As one thinks ahead to the upcoming Breeders’ Cup at Santa Anita, there is a sinking feeling that next week’s season-ending championships could be racing’s Little Bighorn.

The situation is that perilous.

Like Custer’s foes, the sport’s enemies are well armed, determined and will show no mercy.

This all traces back to the disastrous winter at Santa Anita, and the unfathomable outbreak of horse fatalities.

We lay no blame here for the rash of breakdowns. We’ll leave the forensics to others better equipped to analyze the situation.

But we can pose this question: why has the racing industry persisted in holding this year’s Cup at Santa Anita?

The safer course of action would have been a move to another venue, such as Keeneland or Churchill Downs.

We recognize that a location switch is a monumental headache, akin to the NFL having to find a late replacement site for a Super Bowl.

Tickets have been sold; sponsorships secured. The logistics are a nightmare. Sometimes, you simply don’t have a choice.

Santa Anita Park, photo courtesy of Jim Safford Photography

The decision to remain at Santa Anita could come back to haunt.

The breakdowns will be a dominant storyline on the network television coverage and among the few remaining non-industry media outlets that still pay attention to racing.

If the event took place elsewhere, breakdowns would not be front and center. But this is Santa Anita, and this story won’t go away.

Especially when the deaths continue.

Satchel Paige, a 3-year-old gelding, was the latest victim last weekend. He fractured an ankle in a race and was euthanized.

He was the 34th fatality at Santa Anita since December.

To its credit, the Stronach Group, the owners and operators of Santa Anita, were completely transparent. They immediately issued a press release reporting the incident. There was no attempt to bury the bad news.

“The Stronach Group and Santa Anita safety measures put horse and rider safety above all else. Santa Anita and The Stronach Group remain committed to leading transformative change in this traditional sport,” the release said.

Bravo! That should be the standard throughout the sport, whether a Breeders’ Cup race or a $4,000 claimer at Penn National.

For Santa Anita, it comes too late. The reputational damage has already been inflicted.

What a shame. As someone who has covered most Breeders’ Cups since 1989, I can testify that Santa Anita is the ideal host.

It has everything going for it: a perfectly sized facility, ideal weather and a dash of Hollywood glitter and pizzazz.

This time, the breakdowns are the black cloud darkening the proceedings.

Perhaps the racing gods will smile kindly on the beleaguered track and every participant in all 14 Breeders’ Cup championships will come through without incident or injury.

Woe betide racing if there is a breakdown next weekend.

Some of racing’s implacable foes will be sadistically rooting for such a disaster, taking a page from Rahm Emanuel, President Barack Obama’s White House Chief of Staff and former mayor of Chicago, who famously observed that “you never want a serious crisis to go to waste. And what I mean by that is it’s an opportunity to do things that you think you could not before.”

In this case, it’d be abolishing horse racing.

That is certainly the objective of the radical animal rights groups who have already crippled greyhound racing and would love to axe horse racing.

A major injury to a Breeders’ Cup runner would be precisely the ammunition they crave.

Then there is the national media. The New York Times seems to have gone out of its way to present a distorted image of racing as a cesspool in need of cleansing. Earlier this month, the Washington Post ran an opinion piece under the headline “The time for horse racing has passed. It’s time to outlaw it.”

With media friends like that …

Of course, politicians always pile on when an easy target emerges. No less an authority than U.S. Senator Dianne Feinstein (D-California) called for the suspension of racing at Santa Anita earlier this year.

The greater danger here is with the general public who rarely follow the sport. They have now been fed a narrative of Santa Anita as an equine slaughterhouse. They could have the ultimate say if referendums wind up on ballots calling for restrictions or to eliminate horse racing altogether.

The stakes have never been higher for the sport we love.

After the last stand, Custer was widely heralded as a hero. Not everyone agreed.

No less an authority as President Ulysses S. Grant, the ultimate leader of the Union Army in the Civil War, blamed Custer for the massacre and branded the battle “wholly unnecessary — wholly unnecessary.”

Let’s hope “wholly unnecessary” is not the same epitaph for Santa Anita and the 2019 Breeders’ Cup.

Posted on


Proudly featured on: